STUDY: Somalia's COVID-19 deaths 32 times higher than FGS records
MOGADISHU, Somalia - The current COVID-19 deaths in Somalia are grossly undercounted, a study has established, in what could now put the Federal Government of Somalia [FGS] in serious scrutiny, amid ongoing political tussles in the country.
According to the study published by the International Journal of Infectious Diseases, estimates that between 3,200 to 11,800 people died from the effects of COVID-19 between March and September 2020 in the capital, Mogadishu. This is 32 times higher than the reported figures.
Within the same period under the study, the FGS reported 99 deaths and 3,864 positive cases throughout the country. The country has almost a dysfunctional healthcare system and has been depending on donors to supplement the fight against COVID-19.
Somalia reported its first case of COVID-19 on March 16, 2020. To date, the overall death toll given by the Somali government stands at 1,180, and the number of positive cases is at 21,269 in the country.
According to the researchers, there has been a considerable undercount in cases among the Somali population. Several countries led by Turkey, the US, Qatar have been in the frontline in the fight against the pandemic.
"It was not sufficient to assume, as many people had, that Somalia has just been a very lucky country," said Abdihamid Warsame, a research fellow at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine who was among the researchers.
The researchers used satellite images of graves from 2016 to September 2020, as well as interviews and other data collected on the ground to reach the conclusion. Looking at information, there was a substantial increase after COVID-19 arrived in Somalia, Warsame told VOA Somali.
"Having looked at other potential sources of deaths, for example other outbreaks or any other event, we could not find anything else that could account for a large increase in deaths," he said.
But not everyone in Somalia fully supports the results of the research. Somalia country representative for the World Health Organization Dr. Mamunur Rahman Malik says the study lacks some degree of precision.
"I think this number is fine, it is a scientific way of doing things, but may not be truly representative of what deaths or what number of deaths that have actually occurred during this pandemic," he told VOA Somali.
He says the truth might be in between the low fatality number given by the government and the higher figures from the research.
Warsame says he is not arguing all new burials from March to September 2020 translate into deaths and a direct result of COVID-19, but says the pandemic had an impact on the population, which accounted for other deaths.
"During COVID-19 the usage of health services declined, the vaccination decreased, the use of maternal child services decreased, so these could all potentially lead to spike in deaths," he said. "Therefore, COVID-19 could have both direct and indirect impact on deaths."
Malik says the death toll figure given by the government is only based on people who have died of COVID-19 in health facilities. He said the registration system to capture deaths among the community does not exist in Somalia.
"The problem is that there is no definitive registration system for deaths in Somalia, and that is the biggest limitation that we are dealing with," he said.
Banadir, Puntland and Jubaland are the most affected by the pandemic, but the country has enforced various regulations which are being used as mitigation measures. The ban on international flights was lifted to allow businesses to run as normal.